Rethinking Failure and Resistance

Somewhere along the way, many students began treating failure as a personal label rather than a temporary setback. The New York Times once observed that failure has shifted from an action—I failed—to an identity—I am a failure. Any parent who has watched their teen meltdown after a disappointing grade or feedback knows exactly how quickly young people make this leap. Yet every major body of research tells us something very different: failure is not the opposite of success. It is an essential, unavoidable, deeply valuable part of it.

Psychologist Carol Dweck’s work on mindset has helped countless students reframe this experience. Her idea of the “not yet” mindset gives students room to grow instead of shutting down. A tough outcome doesn’t mean they aren’t capable; it means they haven’t yet mastered the material. That single word opens the door to possibility. It reminds students that growth takes time, that learning requires struggle, and that setbacks aren’t proof they should quit—rather, they’re signals to keep going.

Research across psychology echoes this idea:

• Social psychologist Albert Bandura showed that the process of confronting difficulty builds self-efficacy, the internal belief that one can handle hard things.

• Martin Seligman’s work on optimism demonstrated that resilient people interpret setbacks as temporary and specific, rather than defining or permanent.

• Angela Duckworth, who brought the concept of grit into the mainstream, found that perseverance develops from doing difficult things—not from staying comfortable.

When young people are shielded from challenges, she warns, they can become “fragile perfects,” confident only when everything goes right.

Life is full of examples of people who transformed failure into something better.

• Sara Blakely often describes how failing the LSAT twice pushed her toward entrepreneurship and ultimately to founding Spanx.

• Jim Marshall, the Minnesota Vikings player who famously ran the wrong way and scored for the opposing team on national television, didn’t let embarrassment define him. Instead, he used his mistake as motivation to concentrate at a higher level, practice harder than anyone else, and build a remarkable career.

Their stories show that failure doesn’t define someone. What they do afterward does.

This dynamic shows up often in the college application process. In one case, a senior failed a class after assuming the teacher would accept late work for full credit. When that didn’t happen, the outcome was painful—but the experience pushed him to take ownership of his communication and planning in a way nothing else had. That one setback ultimately prepared him far better for the realities of college than any semester of smooth sailing ever could. The failure didn’t define him; it simply illuminated what needed to change.

Colleges increasingly value this kind of resilience. At highly selective colleges, even a single low grade can still hurt a student’s chances. Even with a clear, honest explanation and evidence of growth, the most competitive schools may not be able to overlook it because so many applicants have spotless records.

Admissions officers recognize that the transition to college demands:

• Resilience

• Adaptability

• The ability to bounce back from setbacks

They intentionally look for evidence of reflection in applications.

A student who can explain how they handled a setback—whether academic, personal, or extracurricular—often stands out due to the vulnerability and realization the student demonstrated.

Colleges understand that challenges are inevitable. They want to admit students who can adapt, seek help when needed, and take responsibility for their growth. Resilience predicts success far more accurately than perfection ever will. Parents play a crucial role in helping teens build this capacity. The instinct to fix things for them is understandable, but confidence grows when students work through problems—not when parents solve them.

Teens need reassurance that:

• Effort matters more than flawlessness

• Their worth isn’t tied to GPA

• Every setback contains a lesson—if they’re willing to look for it

Noticing small moments of persistence, kindness, responsibility, and honesty helps them see themselves as capable and grounded, not defined by achievements alone.

Failure, when met with curiosity instead of shame, becomes a turning point.

“Not yet” becomes an invitation to try again, adjust, and grow. And that mindset—the belief that improvement is always possible—is one of the greatest gifts we can give our students as they prepare for college and beyond.

---

Garrett Educational Consulting provides comprehensive counseling for college and boarding school admissions as well as academic advisement. Click HERE to learn about our services.

Prepared especially for our clients and their families The information included in this newsletter is generic and assumes no liability for loss or damage due to reliance on the material contained herein. Copyright © 2025 by The College Advisor, Inc. All rights reserved.